Part of the CustodyStress archive of observed Bitcoin custody incidents
Institutional Failure — Blocked
Cases where institutional failure resulted in permanently blocked access. Exchange insolvency, platform closure, or custodian failure with no viable recovery path — these cases define the irreversible end of the exchange custody failure spectrum.
32 cases in this intersection. 100% of determinate cases resulted in a blocked outcome. The most common recovery path is no path available.
Archive analysis — 32 cases
Outcomes
100% of determinate cases resulted in blocked access — 31 percentage points above the archive-wide average of 69%. Only 0% resulted in recovered access — one of the lower survival rates in the archive.
Custody type
97% of cases involved exchange custody, followed by institutional custody at 3%.
Primary stress condition
94% of cases involve vendor lockout. Legal or authority constraint accounts for a further 6%.
Documentation
97% of cases had present and interpretable documentation — yet still produced a blocked or constrained outcome.
Scale
16% of cases involved large or very large holdings (10+ BTC).
Time distribution
Cases span 2011–2024. Only 6% occurred in 2022 or later — concentrated in earlier periods.
32
Blocked
0
Constrained
0
Survived
0
Indeterminate
100% of determinate cases resulted in blocked or constrained access.
32 observed cases
Blocked
32 (100%)
Blockchain.com Legacy Wallet Lockout: Recovery Phrase Insufficient Without Original Email
Exchange custody
In 2014, delfastTions created a wallet on Blockchain.info and retained the 17-word recovery passphrase—the standard recovery mechanism of that era. Years later,
Three Arrows Capital Collapse: $10B Fund, $3.5B Frozen Claims, Founder Flight
Institutional custody
Three Arrows Capital, founded in 2012 by Zhu Su and Kyle Davies, operated as a cryptocurrency investment fund managing approximately $10 billion in assets throu
Altsbit Exchange Hack (February 2020): Institutional Failure, Partial Recovery
Exchange custody
Altsbit, an Italian cryptocurrency exchange that had been operational for only a few months, suffered a catastrophic security breach in February 2020. Attackers
2.9 BTC in Unidentified Web Wallet from 2012–2013: Provider Unknown, Access Impossible
Exchange custody
In May 2020, a BitcoinTalk user reporting under the handle cyptomania rediscovered Bitcoin documentation while conducting routine record cleanup. The user had s
Livecoin Exchange Compromised by Server Attack — Price Manipulation, Permanent Shutdown
Exchange custody
Livecoin, a Russian cryptocurrency exchange, suffered a critical infrastructure compromise on 23 December 2020 when attackers gained control of the exchange's s
Eterbase Exchange Breach: $5.4M Stolen, Limited Recovery
Exchange custody
On September 8, 2020, Eterbase, a Slovakian cryptocurrency exchange, discovered unauthorised transfers totalling approximately $5.4 million from its hot wallets
MapleChange Exchange Collapse: $5M Missing, Hack Unverified, No Recovery
Exchange custody
MapleChange, a Canadian cryptocurrency exchange, announced on October 28, 2018, that it had suffered a security breach resulting in the loss of approximately $5
BitGrail Exchange Collapse: 17 Million NANO Stolen, 230,000 Users Frozen
Exchange custody
BitGrail, an Italian cryptocurrency exchange, announced on February 8, 2018 that approximately 17 million NANO tokens—valued at roughly $170 million at the time
Yapizon Exchange Hack (April 2017): 3,831 BTC Stolen, Socialised Loss Model Applied to All Users
Exchange custody
On April 22, 2017, Yapizon, a South Korean cryptocurrency exchange, suffered a security breach resulting in the theft of 3,831 BTC—approximately 37% of the exch
Cointrader Exchange Discovers Bitcoin Shortfall, Suspends Operations Indefinitely (March 2016)
Exchange custody
Cointrader operated as a Canadian cryptocurrency exchange with modest activity through early 2016, processing approximately 81 BTC in daily trading volume durin
Bitcurex Exchange Collapse: 2,300 BTC Lost, No Customer Database Backups
Exchange custody
Bitcurex launched in 2012 as Poland's first and largest Bitcoin exchange, processing over $50 million in BTC transactions during its final six months. The platf
Gatecoin Exchange: 250 BTC and 185,000 ETH Drained via Cold Storage Routing Compromise
Exchange custody
Gatecoin Limited operated as a Hong Kong-based cryptocurrency exchange from 2013, gaining credibility through backing by the Hong Kong Science and Technology Pa
796 Exchange — 1,000 BTC Stolen via Withdrawal Address Redirect (January 2015)
Exchange custody
796 was a Chinese cryptocurrency exchange offering spot and futures trading. In late January 2015, the platform discovered a security breach in which an attacke
Vircurex Withdrawal Freeze: Timothy Shaw's 12.85 BTC Locked Since 2014
Exchange custody
Timothy Shaw, a Colorado resident, executed a trade on Vircurex on March 24, 2014, converting his entire dogecoin balance into 12.85 BTC. That same morning, Vir
MintPal/Moolah Exchange Collapse: 3,700 BTC Inaccessible After Ryan Kennedy's Exit Scam
Exchange custody
MintPal was a prominent altcoin exchange serving tens of thousands of users in 2014. Following a July 2014 hack that cost approximately $2 million in VeriCoin,
BTER Cold Wallet Compromise: 7,170 BTC Stolen, Exchange Suspended (February 2015)
Exchange custody
BTER, a Chinese cryptocurrency exchange, suffered a critical custody failure in February 2015 when its cold wallet—the repository for user Bitcoin deposits and
Mt. Gox Exchange Collapse: 750,000 Bitcoin Trapped After February 2014 Withdrawal Halt
Exchange custody
Mt. Gox, the world's largest Bitcoin exchange at the time, announced a complete halt to all Bitcoin withdrawals on February 7, 2014. The exchange attributed the
MintPal Exchange: 3,701 BTC Theft by Operator Ryan Kennedy (2014)
Exchange custody
Ryan Kennedy, operating under the alias Alex Green with a public presence in the Dogecoin community, acquired MintPal—a mid-tier altcoin exchange—in mid-2014. T
Vircurex Exchange Freezes Bitcoin Withdrawals, 1,666 BTC Remains Inaccessible
Exchange custody
Vircurex, founded in October 2011, operated as a custodial cryptocurrency exchange with servers in Beijing but registered falsely as a Belize entity—later deter
BitInstant Exchange Collapse: Charlie Shrem Arrest Freezes Customer Funds
Exchange custody
BitInstant operated as one of the earliest and most prominent custodial Bitcoin exchanges in the United States, co-founded by Charlie Shrem with backing from th
Picostocks Bitcoin Exchange: 7,196 BTC Lost to Insider Theft (2013–2014)
Exchange custody
Picostocks was a custodial Bitcoin exchange that allowed users to hold Bitcoin-denominated shares in various projects. The platform suffered two major theft inc
FXBTC Shanghai Exchange Premature Closure Blocks Customer Withdrawals
Exchange custody
FXBTC was a Shanghai-based cryptocurrency exchange operating during China's early Bitcoin trading boom. In early May 2014, following escalating regulatory press
Cryptsy Exchange Collapse: Concealed Hack Left Users Holding Worthless Balances
Exchange custody
Cryptsy emerged as the dominant altcoin exchange during the 2013 cryptocurrency boom, facilitating trading in Litecoin, Dogecoin, Feathercoin, and hundreds of a
CoinLab vs. Mt. Gox: Partnership Collapse Traps North American Customer Bitcoin in Legal Limbo (May 2013)
Exchange custody
In 2012, Mt. Gox and CoinLab signed a partnership agreement under which CoinLab would assume management of Mt. Gox's US and Canadian customer operations, includ
DHS Seizure of Mt. Gox Dwolla and Wells Fargo Accounts (May 2013)
Exchange custody
On May 15, 2013, the US Department of Homeland Security, acting through Immigration and Customs Enforcement, seized approximately $2.9 million from Mt. Gox's Dw
Translate